How to fit a mag catch in 11 hours or more.
I have had a few things over the years on a 1911 that did not go easy, some things I had to do over. But I never had anything actually beat me. This is a bout as close as I've come to not winning.
It's a mag catch fer cryin' out loud. You drop it in and go, right? Sometimes yes, sometimes no.
A gun I've been working on for a while..... all's well, it's done, just do the polishing and blasting and send it off. 250-ish rounds through it, everything works perfectly, including the mag catch. The mag catch got the standard work-over, to make its motion smooth, with no grit, no hitches-- that by itself is a whole set of steps. Mini-FRAG on the hemispherical button top. The only thing left is, get the right side (keyhole shape) polished to match the frame. That means having it perfectly flush, neither high nor low, polishing lines matching the fore-aft lines of the frame. Throughout the process on this gun it's been sitting about .0035 proud, not prob, take care of it in final polishing. This is about the time I discover that it's possible to pin the mag in the gun by pushing the button too far. In 250-ish rounds it has never happened to me but I fix it by extending the mag catch shaft.
I realize at this point, the the .0035 is variable. If I tap-in the RH side of the mag catch it will go perfectly flush. If I leave it .0035 high and polish off that .0035, at some point it's going to go .0035 below flush. Who TF cares, right? It's less than most human hairs. And me, I'm the guy who rolls my eyes when a guy says,
"OMG, I finally hand-cycled my 1911 once and now there's an awful scratch where the hammer was dragging underneath!". But.... this is a brand-new, high-end custom gun for a discerning customer. I want it to be right in every aspect.
I try.... everything. The body of the mag catch is not a distinct, true diameter and is pretty undersized. I check a few others, they are are the same-ish. I already have a considerable amount of work in this mag catch so I want to use it. It goes to the laser welder (yes, sometimes even new stuff can benefit). I mess around with it the better part of a day and can't get to the bottom of it. Finally: "OK, you WIN!"
I get another mag catch, an extended Nowlin. They have been my fave for a long time. This one does what one hopes for, it does what works for most guns most of the time: it drops in and is close to perfect. But. It too can pin the magazine. And on the button side, what locates it in the mag catch hole is the smaller diameter of the button itself, not the body diameter, which as with the first one, is very undersized. The issue with this? And again, who cares? But at this point--- I will have GD perfection if it kills me-- the issue is, it will wear the bluing off the side of the button diameter, which will be visible. I bet I've done a bunch of guns in the past that do exactly this but now it's personal. In the frame, the button hole and the body hole are perfectly concentric. The button diameter and body diameter of the mag catch are pretty close but with the body being so far undersized..... I silver solder a ring on it and kinda botch the grinding-back-down of it. I mill a slot in it and silver a piece in on the side where it really needs the bump-over and OD grind it to exactly where it needs to be and.... halelujah, I'm there. Extend the mag catch shaft (the other extended one was not a good match), and done. Ish.
Now, "All I have to do" is put mini-FRAG onto the new one.
I silvered a a ring onto it:
That didn’t really get me there so I silvered an insert into it on the side I wanted to bump over:
